Home Latest News

The Prince of Wales, Samuel Smith’s Brewery, and the future of unused historic buildings

An iconic North Shields pub, a historic brewery, and the question of how we give unused buildings a future

By
I Love North Shields
-
530
0

A pub, a brewery, and the question of how we give historic buildings a future

On the Fish Quay, where the River Tyne meets generations of working lives, stands a building that carries more than bricks and mortar. The Prince of Wales pub, known locally and lovingly as the Old Wooden Dolly, is one of North Shields’ most recognisable landmarks — not just because of its position, but because of the stories it holds.

Today, its doors are closed. But its history is anything but quiet.

A site rooted in North Shields life since the 17th century

Records show a pub has existed on this site since at least 1627, placing it among the oldest continuous social spaces in North Shields. The building most people recognise today dates from 1927, identifiable by its distinctive green glazed brickwork — a design choice that tied it visually and culturally to the working Fish Quay.

This was never a destination pub in the modern sense. It was a working pub — used by sailors, fishermen, dock workers and local families. A place to warm up, to talk, to mark departures and returns.

The Wooden Dolly: from figurehead to folklore

The pub’s identity became inseparable from the Wooden Dolly, the fisherwoman effigy that stood nearby on the Quay.

Newspaper archives tell us the original Wooden Dolly was placed around 1814, made from the figurehead of a collier brig undergoing repairs. Initially practical — stopping carts from backing into the river — it quickly became symbolic.

Over time, the Dolly was replaced several times:

  • destroyed by drunken vandals
  • damaged by weather and wear
  • re-carved, including the fourth and current version, a fisherwoman with her creel, carved by Miss Spence

Sailors heading out on long voyages would say goodbye and drink a toast to the Wooden Dolly for luck. Children were warned to behave — or the Wooden Dolly would come for them. By the early 1900s, newspapers already referred to her as a curiosity and landmark, woven into everyday life.

The pub eventually took her name — becoming The Old Wooden Dolly — cementing the connection between building, place and story.

A rare northern outpost of Samuel Smith’s Brewery

The Prince of Wales later became part of Samuel Smith’s Old Brewery, a family-owned brewery founded in 1758 in Tadcaster, Yorkshire — one of the oldest breweries in England.

Sam Smith’s pubs are known for being deliberately traditional:

  • no background music
  • no televisions
  • limited or no mobile phone use
  • simple interiors
  • an emphasis on conversation and calm

This approach has earned both loyalty and criticism, but it is rooted in a clear philosophy: pubs as places for human connection, not distraction.

In 1992, after a period of closure, Sam Smith’s restored the Prince of Wales in a traditional style and reopened it — preserving much of the building’s character rather than modernising it beyond recognition. That decision is one reason the pub remains so authentic today.

Why buildings like this struggle — even when they matter

Across the UK, pubs face enormous pressures: rising costs, staffing challenges, changing habits and tight margins. Traditional pubs face an additional challenge — their very quietness can feel out of step with expectations shaped by louder, experience-led hospitality.

Sam Smith’s often looks for couples to run its pubs, offering training and accommodation. But for places like the Old Wooden Dolly, that’s not always an easy match. Long hours, financial uncertainty and a strict operating model can deter people — especially younger generations without savings or security.

The result? Historic buildings that matter deeply can sit unused, not because they lack value, but because the gap between ownership, operation and community becomes too wide.

Learning from elsewhere: calm spaces still work

Across Europe, particularly in cities like Amsterdam, there’s growing interest in “slow social” spaces — cafés and meeting places with:

  • no Wi-Fi
  • no phone use
  • no background music
  • a focus on reading, talking, board games and presence

These spaces work not because they chase trends, but because they offer relief from them. They show that quiet, tech-light social spaces are not outdated — they’re increasingly needed.

That philosophy isn’t far removed from the Sam Smith’s model. In fact, it aligns closely with it.

Rethinking use — without erasing identity

Not every historic building needs to operate at full commercial capacity to justify its existence. Some need hybrid or interim uses that keep them alive while respecting their character.

For a place like the Old Wooden Dolly, future uses could include:

  • a limited-hours, conversation-led pub
  • a heritage-focused space telling Fish Quay stories
  • a calm community meeting place
  • a venue for local history talks, reading groups or exhibitions
  • a shared stewardship model where community involvement supports long-term sustainability

These aren’t radical ideas. They’re rooted in how the building has always been used.

Why this matters now

North Shields is changing. There’s renewed pride in heritage, creativity and place — but that only works if the physical anchors of those stories remain accessible.

When buildings like the Old Wooden Dolly sit empty, we don’t just lose a pub. We lose:

  • a shared memory space
  • a sense of continuity
  • a living link between past and present

Preserving heritage isn’t about freezing places in time. It’s about allowing them to keep working — socially, culturally, emotionally — even as their use evolves.

A future built on respect

The Old Wooden Dolly has survived for centuries because it mattered to people. That still holds true.

The challenge now is not whether it has value — but how owners, operators and community might work together to bridge the gap between tradition and viability, ensuring this iconic building continues to belong to North Shields.

Some places don’t need reinventing.
They just need opening — thoughtfully.

Links & Sources

🏛️ History of the Prince of Wales / Old Wooden Dolly

🗞️ Newspaper & Archive References

🍺 Samuel Smith’s Old Brewery

📉 Wider Context: Pubs & Pressures

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR